Writing Family History Without Starting a Family Argument

OPINION
By Richard Evans, President Whitsundays Writers Festival

Ask two relatives about the same Christmas lunch and you may hear two different stories. One remembers Uncle Jack’s joke about the pudding; the other remembers the remark that stung for years. Both are sincere. Both are, in their way, true.

When writing family history, your task is not to prove who was right. It is to preserve what happened, what it meant to you, and why it still matters.

In my novel Horrible People, I drew on my own pre-selection battles as a former federal Member of Parliament: the lies and political manipulation of those who would have preferred I was not in Parliament. As the title suggests, I didn’t think much of them. But turning those events into fiction let me explore motives, consequences, and moral grey areas without putting any real person on trial.

Memoir asks something similar of us. When we write about family, we are not simply reporting facts. We are interpreting a life from where we stood. A sister, brother, parent, or cousin may have stood somewhere else, and seen another truth.

Three simple rules can help.

  • Own your perspective. Phrases such as “As I understood it”, “In my memory” or “From where I stood” signal honesty without surrendering your story.
  • Separate the event from the verdict. Describe what happened, how it affected you and what you understand now. Resist turning the page into an indictment.
  • Protect what need not be public. Ask whether a detail is essential to the story or merely wounding. If it isn’t essential, leave it out. Use initials or changed names, or write privately first.

Where accounts clash, treat the disagreement as part of the record. It is perfectly fair to write, “My brother remembers it differently,” or “Mum always said the farm was sold for another reason.”

You might also look at old letters, photographs, and records, or talk to older relatives. Let the evidence and the memories sit side by side. The aim is curiosity, not judgement.

Your writing challenge this week

Choose one family event that is still told in different ways. Write 300 words in your journal about it from your own point of view. Include one sentence acknowledging that someone else may remember it differently.

A family story does not need to win an argument to be true. Sometimes its greatest value is that it allows several truths to be heard.